For most families, the number one criteria when choosing a town IS the school system. I see my clients struggling to make the BEST decision for their children, because it is perhaps THE MOST important factor when deciding where to live.
Prefer to watch? The full breakdown is above. The written version continues below.
And as a father, I also FEEL the incredible burden, because I know that the education choices we make WILL have a profound impact on our children's life.
So today, I am going to show you the method that will give you the confidence to know you are focused on the best schools FOR YOUR CHILDREN'S NEEDS.
If this is the first time we are meeting, my name is Charlie Vinci. I have helped 100's of families relocate here from all over the world.
Full disclosure before we go any further: I am a Connecticut Realtor, and I am going to use Connecticut as an example, because it's what I know best. But the truth is, it doesn't matter whether you are looking in Jersey, Long Island, Westchester or Connecticut. The method works because it's based on fundamentals.
First, Why the Ratings Sites Aren't a Magic Bullet
Before we dive into the filters which will help you pick the best school — and therefore town — let's talk about the filters which are too heavily relied upon, and why they aren't a magic bullet. I am of course talking about the ratings you find on Niche, Great Schools and others.
I am going to number out the many ways they can be misleading.
One
The score may track the families, not the teaching
When researchers have reverse-engineered these ratings, they've found the score tracks the income and education level of the families already living there almost as closely as anything about the actual teaching.
Two
A raw test score tells you where the kids started
A raw test score tells you where the kids started — and in an affluent town, they start ahead no matter what the school does. You may actually want growth: how much the school moves a child from September to June. A school packed with already-advantaged kids can post gorgeous scores while a school that's adding real value can look "average."
Three
One tidy digit blends everything together
That 8-out-of-10 score is averaging academics, test scores, cafeteria food quality, sometimes parent reviews, sometimes diversity, into one tidy digit. If what matters to your family is the arts program, or special-ed support, or class size, that detail got blended into mush with the lunch menu. The number can't tell you about the one thing that decides whether your child will thrive in that atmosphere.
Four
The reviews come from the extremes
The parents who fill the reviews are usually the most thrilled or the most furious, so will they actually reflect your experience?
Five
The data is a reflection of the past
The data is a reflection of the past, so a new principal or a recent slide may not be visible.
Six
A "9" in one state isn't a "9" in another
This one is especially relevant if you're comparing suburbs across state lines. A "9" in one state and a "9" in another come from totally different tests with different definitions of what is considered proficient. Comparing them straight across tells you almost nothing. I'll give you better tools to help you equalize across state lines.
Use the ratings as a starting point — a way to build your list, not finish it. They tell you where to look. They do not tell you what you'll find.
The Six Filters
The filters I'm about to give you are how you actually find the best school for your children.
There are six common filters. The wrong way to use them would be to value all of them equally, because, well, your child isn't the same as someone else's. A more effective approach would be to prioritize the filters. Make a big list of all the school possibilities, and then filter them through your prioritized list of filters. Once you are down to a few schools, dig deep to choose the best for your child. Here's how.
Filter One
The Assignment Filter
Applicable only when you are considering public schools. You will want to find the official source for your town. My team built a school district map for our local towns, and I can tell you they are incredibly difficult to make, because the street by street detail is nearly impossible, and the town can change the rules with little warning.
So what you want to do is find the official source — for local towns, those sources are linked in the buyers guides on my website.
Then, you will want to look up the specific address. Notice that the street number and whether you are an even or odd number can make a difference. The point is, the devil is in the details, so be sure to double check the official school assignment, no matter what any website or agent told you, and do it before you make an offer on a home.
Filter Two
The Learning Style Filter
I would imagine that a confident, adaptable kid is going to be fine almost anywhere. But if you've got a child with a learning difference, fit likely becomes a top rated filter and everything else is noise.
What opened up my eyes is how many possibilities there are across the New York City Metro. Here's a brief list to give you an idea of what's possible here:
Dyslexia & structured-literacy intervention is good for a child who's a struggling reader or dyslexic.
Executive-function coaching is good for a child who has ADHD or just can't get organized.
On-site speech, occupational, and physical therapy is good for a child who needs those services woven into the day, not crammed into afternoon appointments.
Gifted & talented programming is good for a child who races ahead.
Twice-exceptional support is good for a child who's gifted and wired differently.
A neurodiversity-affirming culture is good for a child who's autistic or ADHD and needs to be accepted, not pressured to mask all day.
Real ELL scaffolding is good for a child whose first language isn't English — a bright kid learning a language, not a struggling student.
My clients typically prioritize this filter when their child has an obvious learning difference.
Filter Three
The Duration Filter
How long do you expect your child to be in the school system? Do you relocate often? Or is this a long term plan?
If you move every few years you want ease of entry and exit, and a curriculum that travels. This is where something like the IB program quietly wins. It was created so that internationally mobile families could move their kids between countries without the curriculum resetting, and it's available at select high schools across the NYC metro.
Locally it is currently available at the International School at Dundee in Greenwich, and Stamford High School.
But if you're putting down roots, the long game is most likely the focus. It's not necessarily about the early years, but the lifetime relationships that will be built, and the quality of the final years which are of course, the college launching point.
Filter Four
The Human Filter
Remember how I said the school ratings are a look backwards. They reflect what the school did a year or two ago. Not next year. You overcome this concern with the human filter. Talk to parents who are entrenched in the school system. This one is best saved to finalize your decision, and it's only effective if you ignore the single furious parent and the breathless superfan.
You can ask the admission office for names, many have a school ambassador program. There are community groups like Facebook and Nextdoor. Or how about emailing the president of the PTO and asking if they would meet for a cup of coffee?
Once the conversation is warmed up, you will want to ask something like: With everything you know today, do you still believe this school was the best choice?
Filter Five
The Finance Filter
If you can pay the cost of your child's education, no matter the cost, your options are broad. But the reality is that some of the public schools across the New York City Metro are considered better than many of our private schools.
The cost of a good public school is the price of a home and the taxes. You might consider it an investment. Many of my clients have stretched into towns with a perfect school fit and found a way to make them more affordable. They sometimes stretch their budget, buy at the entry points, and OR move up later or renovate. They also find that when it comes time to sell, there is a long list of buyers for homes in compelling school districts. Compare that with the cost of private school tuition, and the real math reveals itself.
Filter Six
The State Equalization Filter
Earlier I told you that a 9 in one state wasn't equal to a 9 in another state. Luckily, if you are considering two states, there are a few tools to help you compare them.
The cheat code is simple: across state lines, throw out the star ratings. Pull the Stanford data for the honest grade-level comparison, sanity-check it with SAT and AP — they are the same test everywhere. And you will have a clearer picture of how the 2 schools rank when compared to each other.
The ratings tell you where to look. These six filters tell you what you'll find.
Schools Are Only One Part of the Decision
But the truth is, schools are only one part of your decision. We love our kids, but we need a little something for ourselves too. That's why I created this series, and there's lots more to come.
Start With the Official Sources, Not the Star Ratings
The district maps, the official school assignment lookups, and the town-by-town detail I use with relocating families are all collected in the buyers guides on my site — organized by town, so you can run the Assignment Filter on a real address before you ever write an offer.
If you want help prioritizing the six filters for your own family, that's the conversation I have every week.
Explore Greenwich